Listen Live!
join BAW
forgot password
LIFE
WORK
PLAY


blAck americaweb.com

Commentary: Conservative Media Cries Injustice Over Duke Rape Claims, Yet Clam Up When Victims are Black

Date: Thursday, May 25, 2006
By: Gregory Kane, BlackAmericaWeb.com

Conservative pundits and columnists won’t let the story of rape allegations against the Duke lacrosse team go.

Now, thanks to a story in The Baltimore Sun, I think I know why.

Last week, black conservative Thomas Sowell wrote what was at least his second column on the Duke lacrosse matter. Sowell, like television talk show hosts Sean Hannity and Tucker Carlson and radio commentator Rush Limbaugh, went on at length about what an injustice is being done to the three white Duke lacrosse players who have been charged with raping a black North Carolina Central University co-ed.

That same week, The Sun ran a story about the third Duke player indicted in the case. David F. Evans is a local boy, from Bethesda, Md., who played on the lacrosse team of the Landon School. Deep in the story, we read that “Evans’ mother is a founder of a Washington-based lobbying and consulting firm. Gossip columns have noted her friendship with Marilyn Quayle, wife of former Vice President Dan Quayle.”

You may remember Quayle as the conservative Republican who was vice president under President George Herbert Walker Bush. We can’t say for certain what happened as a result of the friendship between Evans’ mother and Marilyn Quayle, but we can speculate, can’t we?

Mom calls Marilyn, who tells hubby, who calls conservative buddies in politics, who call conservative buddies in media. All of a sudden, we have a horde of conservative columnists and talk show hosts talking injustice who barely mentioned the word before, certainly not when it happened to po’ folks.

Anybody remember Sowell writing about what happened in Tulia, Texas in 1999? Anybody remember Carlson, Hannity or Limbaugh talking about it?

I thought not.

If you’re a columnist or television host -- and your politics shouldn’t matter -- if you want to talk about an injustice in the criminal justice system, what happened in Tulia is a textbook case of it. An “undercover” police officer named Tom Coleman, a known thief and perjurer, sent over 20 people to prison based on his uncorroborated testimony. Most of the people were black. A couple were white and Hispanic. Some were men and some were women. All were poor.

You see already how that differs from the Duke case, don’t you? All the suspects in that case are rich, white males.

Now, if you’re a conservative columnist or talk show host writing about or talking about a perceived injustice that could happen to three white males, that’s certainly your privilege. But if you were silent about what happened in Tulia, you have to know people will challenge your credibility when you write about the “injustice” of what’s happening to the three indicted Duke lacrosse players. Why, folks might actually believe you only get excited about “injustice” when it happens to rich white guys.

I did a Lexis Nexis search of Thomas Sowell and Tulia. It turns out Sowell hasn’t written word one about what happened in Tulia. A Lexis Nexis search of Tulia, along with Hannity, Carlson and Limbaugh reveals none of them has written or commented in print journalism about the Tulia matter. When it comes to Tulia, the lips of this conservative quartet have been welded so tightly shut that you couldn’t pry them open with a blow torch and a jackhammer.

How bad was what happened in Tulia? How much time do you have?

Coleman, the cop, wore no wire. There was no documentation of his alleged drug transactions with the defendants, except for the notes he scribbled on his leg.

That’s right: Coleman’s idea of “documentation” was to simply roll up his pants and write on either leg.

According to the 2005 book “Tulia: Race, Cocaine and Corruption in a Small Texas Town” by Nate Blakeslee, one of the judges who presided over one of the cases knew that Coleman committed perjury in a preliminary hearing and still let him testify against one of the defendants. Not only that, the same judge wouldn’t allow the defense to present evidence to the jury about Coleman’s criminal history.

Some of the defendants were hit with sentences as long as 361 years due to Coleman’s mischief, for nothing more than possessing small amounts of cocaine. Others were innocent people lied into prison by Coleman.

The next time you hear or read Sowell, Carlson, Hannity or Limbaugh talking about injustice in the Duke lacrosse case, shoot them an e-mail or give them a phone call and ask them where their voices were when injustice was occurring in Tulia, Texas.




Discuss

Jay_Mac says:

This is exactly the point I was trying to drive home to some other posters that both parties are screwing read more

khrishill says:

Thanks for the comments. I apologize for any assumptions on my part regarding Huggy. I appreciate the comments that when read more

Geminisis says:

OK I'll say just one word - Leprosy - LOL!!!

Geminisis says:

Geminisis says:

I'm such an damn hypchondriac.

More Headlines

Commentary: Great, There’s a Woman on the GOP Ticket – Too Bad She’s the Wrong Woman for the Job

Tapping Sarah Palin as his running mate is as much a mockery and corruption of identity politics as was George H.W. Bush’s selection of Clarence Thomas for the high court.

Commentary: Their V.P. Nominee’s Kin Proves the Hypocrisy of Republicans’ Stance on Sex Education

When Sen. John McCain named Alaska Gov. Sarah Palin as his running mate, he helped expose the deep hypocrisies of the Republican party.

Commentary: Trust Me, Republicans, Going After Obama for His ‘Terrorist Ties’ is a Very Bad Idea

A word of advice to my fellow Republicans: You don't want to make an issue of Sen. Barack Obama’s friendship with William Ayers. That wouldn't be wise.

Commentary: If Politics Isn’t Child’s Play, Why Should Sarah Palin Get the Kid-Gloves Treatment?

It seems there’s a lot more drama tucked into the resume of GOP vice presidential candidate Sarah Palin than rank-and-file Republicans were led to believe.

Commentary: On Kids’ Achievement Gap, Biden May Have Been Correct Before He Became Politically Correct

The Delaware senator didn't mean to imply that black students were inherently academically inferior to their white and Asian counterparts. Or did he?

Commentary: Hopefully, ‘The Wire’ Star Who Got Tripped Up Will Realize the Idiocy in the ‘No Snitching’ Mentality

Boy, talk about life imitating art that was imitating life. Felicia "Snoop" Pearson, who played a homicidal character on "The Wire," is back in jail.

Commentary: One Thing Monday Night’s Speech Set Straight for Sure? Michelle Obama is No ‘Baby Mama’

Michelle Obama is no baby mama. But let's hope that the real baby mamas, and for that matter, the baby daddies, were tuned in Monday night -- and taking notes.



Copyright © 2001-2005 BlackAmericaWeb.com, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
About Us | Advertise | Help | Privacy Policy | Search | Terms of Use | Unsubscribe