Listen Live!
join BAW
forgot password
LIFE
WORK
PLAY


blAck americaweb.com

Commentary: Neither Speech Nor Sermon Could Explain the Complexity of the Black Experience in America

Date: Monday, May 05, 2008
By: Deborah Mathis, BlackAmericaWeb.com

For Barack Obama, or anyone else, to be asked to explain black American culture is not unlike being asked that old empiricist question, “What is the meaning of life?”

The answer requires another question: How much time do you have?

In at least two instances, Obama has been faced with this dilemma -- first, three months ago, after his wife, Michelle, told a Milwaukee audience that “for the first time in my adult life, I am really proud of my country;” and now, in the relentless hoopla over his former pastor’s sermonic thunderclaps.

His attempts to elaborate about the how’s and why’s have only been frustrated by the media and public’s infamously short attention span and a craving for the short, sweet kernel that’s wrapped in a 10- to 20-second sound bite.






Obama went far in Philadelphia in March, trying to compress a nuanced, complicated and deeply historical matter into a chewable nugget. Even non-supporters gave him kudos for venturing onto terrain that had no modern politician had touched before.

A lot of people were listening when he delivered that treatise, but you have to wonder now how many people heard him -- which is to say, got him? Based on the incessant harping about the Rev. Jeremiah Wright that threatens to dog the candidate till the end, you’d have to say not enough were able to handle such a big meal.

This was bound to happen to the first black person with a serious shot at the U.S. presidency. Whoever that pioneer had been (and whenever), he or she was going to be asked to explain, rationalize, unwrap and dissect elements of the black American culture -- not because they were new, but because they were particularized, if not unique. And because, until that point, non-black America refused to pay attention.

What the rest of the country understands about us, on the whole, comes from the point where black culture spills out of its neighborhoods and into the mainstream. And, in the absence of an understanding about what went on before that cresting, superficial impressions -- ergo, stereotypes -- thrive.

They have seen the markers of hip hop -- the music, the clothing, the lingo -- and they think they know our kids. They have been exposed to gospel music, and they think they know our churches. They know that we are disproportionately poor, have higher unemployment rates, suffer higher incarceration rates and shorter life expectancies, and they think they know our values.

The Quick Fixers don’t want to be bothered with cause and effect; they don’t want to dig at the root of a situation, preferring the flowering weed. To borrow from Rev. Wright’s theme, the differences are mistaken as deficiencies.
 
Try, if you will, to unravel that in a single conversation or even a hundred. Try to explain that we are masters at compartmentalization, refusing to be taken in or taken down by every injustice, lest we turn into full-time fighters. Just as we can take a slight in the workplace or at the bank or in the cab line and move on, we can hear a preacher say things that offend us and hold our seats. We are discerning creatures, not lemmings, after all.

Now, go tell that.

The fact is, you can read black history in a book, but you can’t live it there. You can’t impart it in a sermon nor even in a long and thoughtful speech in Philadelphia. You can’t pick it up by dropping your pants below your rump or by corn-rowing your hair.

Whether it registers is still another matter. Unfortunately, the public clamors for a simplicity that belies the black experience. And not even the erudite, enchanting Barack Obama can fix that.




Discuss

SheHear says:

br>
Like Lou Dobbs, Rush Limbaugh, Sean Hannity, John McCain, and Mitt Romney, many pundits were praying that Senator read more

cjhud50 says:

the problem is with folks like the good reverend and good caring people like Deborah that blacks have not been read more

demp109 says:

A man can't explain the complexity of a woman and vice-versa. We still have to find a way read more

Theloneous says:

Unfortunately, the public (the functionally literate over 30 white American demographic) clamors for a simplicity that belies the black experience."< read more

hseman91 says:

You are one of those that only look at what you see. Blacks act like they do for the same read more



  web blackamericaweb.com
Google


Click Here!

More Headlines

Commentary: Bush’s Support for African AIDS Relief Could Be the Bright Spot in an Otherwise Dark Legacy

Despite his administration’s deceptive, bullying approach to foreign policy, Bush has slowly but surely shown his support for Africa and her people.

The Hutchinson Report: Don’t Knock Disgraced Track Star Marion Jones for Asking the President for a Pardon

Even a contrite Jones agreed that she should do time. But that doesn’t mean she doesn’t have the right to ask President Bush for a pardon -- or even get one.

Commentary: Okay, Black America – What Are We Going to Do About Douglass High Schools All Over the Country?

You have to wonder what Frederick Douglass would think of the school named after him in Baltimore, which has one of the most dismal academic records in the state of Maryland.

Commentary: Josephine Baker’s Story a Reminder of How Much We Can Achieve When Our Talents are Respected

Paris was the place where Baker, with her famed banana dance and other performances, defied an American society bent on defining black people by their otherness.

Commentary: Environmentalists Want You to Save the Planet? They Could Start By Helping You Save Your Green

The problem with living green is the same problem with absolution bought with gold: The more money you have, the more morally superior you can become.

Commentary: Obama’s Presidency Won’t Be the End-All-Be-All for Black America, But It Will Begin the U-Turn

For all of his exceptional qualities and remarkable potential, I fully expect to be disappointed, even angered, by a President Obama from time to time.

Commentary: We Talk About How Ministers’ Kids Tend to Be Wild – What About the Preachers Themselves?

Jesse Jackson. James Bevel. And yes, Martin Luther King. It’s clear now that all three of these men -- all reverends -- had a side few ever knew.



Copyright © 2001-2005 BlackAmericaWeb.com, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
About Us | Advertise | Help | Privacy Policy | Search | Terms of Use | Unsubscribe